Classic Southern Pecan Pie, 9" Deep Dish

Bring a taste of Southern tradition to your table with Priester’s Classic Southern Pecan Pie. Our 9-inch deep-dish pecan pie features carefully selected pecans, a rich, buttery filling, and a flaky, made-from-scratch crust. Fully baked and ready to serve, it arrives in a signature Priester’s gift box—ready for family gatherings, holiday celebrations, or a thoughtful gift.

510 Test Pies. One Family Recipe.

When Priester’s set out to create the perfect Southern pecan pie, we took the task seriously—510 test pies seriously. Our family and bakers tested recipes from throughout the community, searching for exceptional flavor, beautiful appearance, and a filling that would slice beautifully and travel well.

After all that testing, the winning recipe was right in the family all along: Mother May’s treasured pecan pie recipe.

Baked by Priester’s since 1987, this family favorite delivers the old-fashioned Southern flavor that makes pecan pie worth sharing. From its generous pecan filling to its flaky crust, every slice brings a little Southern hospitality to the table.

Why You’ll Love Our Classic Southern Pecan Pie

• Treasured family recipe: Made using Mother May’s recipe, chosen after 510 test pies.

• A Priester’s tradition: Baked by Priester’s since 1987.

• Generous deep-dish size: Each 9-inch pie serves approximately 8 people.

• Classic Southern flavor: Carefully selected pecans and a rich, buttery filling.

• Made-from-scratch crust: A flaky crust that complements every bite.

• Ready to enjoy: Fully baked, with no baking required.

• Beautifully gift boxed: Presented in a signature Priester’s gift box.

• Delivered with care: Carefully packaged for nationwide shipping.

A Southern Favorite for Celebrations and Gifts

Serve our Classic Southern Pecan Pie at Thanksgiving dinner, Christmas gatherings, birthdays, or Sunday supper. Enjoy a slice on its own, or add vanilla ice cream or whipped cream for an extra-special dessert.

Sending something sweet? Our gift-boxed pecan pie makes a thoughtful choice for family, friends, hosts, customers, and clients. Have it delivered to your own table or shipped directly to someone special.

Pie Size: 9-Inch Deep Dish
Servings: Approximately 8 per pie
Preparation: Fully baked and ready to serve
Presentation: Signature Priester’s gift box

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Priester’s Classic Southern Pecan Pie special?

Our family and bakers tested 510 pies before choosing Mother May’s treasured family recipe. We’ve been baking it since 1987, pairing carefully selected pecans with a rich, buttery filling and a flaky, made-from-scratch crust.

What size is the pie, and how many people does it serve?

Each pie is a 9-inch deep-dish pecan pie that serves approximately 8 people, depending on slice size.

Does the pecan pie arrive ready to serve?

Yes. Our Classic Southern Pecan Pie is fully baked and ready to serve, with no baking required. Follow the instructions included with your pie for storage and any warming directions.

Can I order a pecan pie online for delivery?

Yes. Order Priester’s Classic Southern Pecan Pie online for delivery to your home or directly to a gift recipient. Each pie is carefully packaged for nationwide shipping.

Can I send this pecan pie as a gift?

Absolutely. Each pie is presented in a signature Priester’s gift box, making it a thoughtful gift for holidays, birthdays, thank-yous, customer appreciation, and other special occasions.

Can I order ahead for Thanksgiving or Christmas?

Yes. Order ahead for your celebration, select from the available shipping options at checkout, and follow the storage instructions included with your pie.

How should I store my pecan pie?

Follow the storage instructions included with your pie to maintain its flavor and quality. For questions about refrigeration, freezing, or planning ahead for an event, contact Priester’s before ordering.

Prefer a Single-Serving Pecan Pie?

Enjoy traditional Southern flavor in a smaller size with our Mini Pecan Pies. These individual treats are a delicious choice for dessert tables, entertaining, gifting, or enjoying a little something sweet.

Shop Mini Pecan Pies →