Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies

Was: $27.99
On Sale $24.35
(86 reviews) Write a Review
SKU:
107
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Our Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies are a timeless dessert that embodies the essence of Southern cooking. Made with love and a decades-old recipe passed down through generations, these pies capture the comforting flavors of pecans, buttery pastry, and sweet filling.

Our Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies are baked to perfection, creating a harmonious blend of flaky crust and rich, gooey filling. Each bite is a nostalgic trip down memory lane, evoking images of family gatherings and cherished traditions.

These pies are crafted with the finest and freshest ingredients, ensuring an exceptional flavor experience. The star of the show is, of course, the premium pecans. Each pie is generously filled with an abundance of buttery pecans, perfectly toasted to enhance their natural nutty profile.

Whether you're serving these pies at a holiday feast or simply indulging in a slice after a long day, our Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies are sure to delight your taste buds and warm your heart. Taste the legacy of Southern baking with every bite of these classic and irresistible pies.

What are the ingredients used in the Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies?

Our Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies are made with a combination of high-quality ingredients, including pecans, sugar, corn syrup, eggs, butter, and traditional pie crust.

Do Priester's Pecan Pies ship fresh?

Your pecan pie arrives on your doorstep (or the doorstep of your gift recipient) as fresh as the day we made it. Choose from one, two, or six 9" pies in gift boxes to keep for yourself (we won't judge!) or share with family and friends.

Is it necessary to refrigerate the Old-Fashioned Pecan Pies?

We recommended refrigerating our pecan pies after they've been opened. Pecan pies are considered "egg-rich" pies, and the USDA advises storing them in the fridge to prevent any potential bacterial growth. Refrigerating the pecan pie helps maintain its freshness and prevents the filling from cracking and ruining the presentation!

Nut Variety:
Pecan
Packaging:
Boxes
Packaging:
Bulk

Related Products

Reviews

  • So Buttery!

    5

    Posted by Amy S. on Sep 16th 2024

    Hands down the best Pecan Pie I've ever had. So buttery, full of pecans, and a flakey homestyle crust. Arrived in a beautiful gift box and in perfect condition. MMMMMMMM!

  • Yummy

    5

    Posted by Kenneth W. Collins from Carmichael, CA on Dec 13th 2023

    Best pecan pies in the world, my personal opinion. I grew up in the mid-west where pecan trees grew in abundance, so pecan pies frequently appeared as dessert. Priester's Pecan Pies rival those made by my mother.

  • Really Yummy!

    5

    Posted by Katy McCain from Enid, OK on Dec 6th 2023

    So, sad little story... my mom passed a year ago and her tradition to make at Thanksgiving was a chocolate chip pecan pie (we call it a Derby Pie in the South). Well, no one really had time to make that and bring it, so I saw that Priester had this with the regular pie (for those kind-of watching their weight), and so I got it delivered to my parents' home and it was delicious. It really did taste so much like my mom's. Thank you Priester for offering that combo!

  • Thanksgiving pies

    5

    Posted by Patricia Basham from McMinnville, TN on Dec 6th 2023

    Pies were wonderful. My favorite was the chocolate pecan pies.

  • Best Pecan Pie

    5

    Posted by Carol Anne Lee from Fayetteville, GA on Dec 5th 2023

    The best Pecan pie ever! So many pecans on each pie! The filling is delicious and the crust is not sweet, which compliments the rest of the pie. It's the best Pecan pie that I've ever put in my mouth!!

  • Best Ever

    5

    Posted by Richard W. Boone, Sr. from Falls Church, VA on Dec 5th 2023

    The chocolate pecan pie is, hands down, the best store bought pecan pie I have ever eaten.

  • Best pies ever

    5

    Posted by Marilyn J. Morris from Warrenton, GA on Nov 28th 2023

    This is the second year I have ordered pecan pies and they are the best tasting pies. My grandson begged me to order but surprise I had already ordered

  • Awesome!

    5

    Posted by Jeanie from Rush, KY on Nov 28th 2023

    The pecan pie was awesome! I would order again. I got it for my husband's birthday! He would rather have the pie instead of cake!

  • My review

    5

    Posted by SUSAN MORGAN from Covington, LA on Mar 2nd 2023

    I purchased this pecan pie for my in-laws for Valentines Day. The pie was delicious & it arrived on time as stated it would. I ordered a pecan variant tin for Christmas & my in-laws thoroughly enjoyed it. This time I wanted to send a pie. They were thrilled to receive it. I would recommend these products to anyone.